SRL Archive - News and General

Rsbot vs Scar?


bukowski

2009-01-06 19:39:30

Ive heard about RSbot, tried it once. But the people were lame over there. How does Rsbot work compared to scar? is it better?

sheffy101

2009-01-06 19:44:28

First vote,
w00t!
personally i think rsbot is garbage,

noidea

2009-01-06 19:49:14

Sorry mate, but tbh I think this should be closed. THere have been 30 of these threads…

Luski14

2009-01-06 19:49:29

RSBot is garbage.

That have:

  • Inexperienced Scripters
  • Little to ZERO Anti-Randoms
  • Bad Community - Not fun to hang around
  • SRL/SCAR is jsut a cooler name :D

P1nky

2009-01-06 20:15:08

yeah ffs stop making these kind of threads, its yall's choise dont ask us lol, and ofc you posted in srl site… so majority will be scar ffs.

post on RSBOT site….
they'll vote RSBOT lol


this aint General news >=(

Method

2009-01-06 21:56:20

From: Luski14
RSBot is garbage.

That have:

  • Inexperienced Scripters
  • Little to ZERO Anti-Randoms
  • Bad Community - Not fun to hang around
  • SRL/SCAR is jsut a cooler name :D


I really don't think any of these are true (though they all involve your own opinion, which of course can't be incorrect).

Also, you can't really compare SCAR (and SRL) and RSBot because both work in very different ways. Try both out and see what you like better, and then make a choice for yourself.

Shady?

2009-01-06 22:16:49

Posted way too many times…

fl4k3s

2009-01-06 22:41:08

From: Luski14
RSBot is garbage.

That have:

  • Inexperienced Scripters
  • Little to ZERO Anti-Randoms
  • Bad Community - Not fun to hang around
  • SRL/SCAR is jsut a cooler name :D


I don't know about Inexperienced script writers, they maybe some but not as many as SRL, but I've been an SRL member for a couple of days now, and the community is great, and lastly SRL DOES SOUND MUCH BETTER!

SRL FTW!:bart:

ConneX

2009-01-06 23:51:38

Ofc scar won,rsbot is easier to use and install scripts but get always banned.

Freddy1990

2009-01-07 15:26:21

There's no comparison between the two, they're 2 completely different things…

noidea

2009-01-07 15:28:32

From: Freddy1990
There's no comparison between the two, they're 2 completely different things…


+1;

Java and Delphi/Pascal are completely different with different capabilities.

DaWu

2009-01-07 16:18:51

Its just a fact, that with java + all the reflection stuff, inexperienced scripter is capable of making as reliable scripts as experienced SCAR scripter.

But this is just pointless, SCAR is all about dodging the bans, being very hardly detectable. Java bots are usually slow functioning (example; dropping ), but then again reliable in many ways.

This is very pointless as stated before; SCAR is delphi/pascal and RSbot is java, both languages have their strong and weak sides, you just have to choose what you prefer.

People commonly claim javabots are more detectable, no they arent, they just lack multiplayer rotating + usualy are capable of doing overnight runs with just one character, and that does lead to ban in long run, because one characters ingame time/day starts to look suspicious, and will draw jagex's attention

koo29

2009-01-07 16:54:44

I once tried to get RSbot2, but when i went to the site where I get it, my bitdefender said that it just had blocked a virus. Very nice try form them…

Scaper

2009-01-07 19:18:35

wtf you come to a scar/SRL forum and post things like this whats the point if you want banned faster go back to rsbot

Scar <3 freddy & SRL <3 fawaki & wizzup? & Devs& the people whomake it what it is

Scar FTW

Maninpink5

2009-02-06 20:53:33

Tried to download RSbot once and my virus protection said it detected a trojan. So im guessing keylogger? Plus SRL community is way better.:)

Method

2009-02-06 21:04:54

From: Maninpink5
Tried to download RSbot once and my virus protection said it detected a trojan. So im guessing keylogger? Plus SRL community is way better.:)


No, RSBot doesn't contain any sort of malware.

MylesMadness

2009-02-06 21:18:16

From: Maninpink5
Tried to download RSbot once and my virus protection said it detected a trojan. So im guessing keylogger? Plus SRL community is way better.:)
It said it was a trojan so you though it was a keylogger?

Smarter Child

2009-02-06 21:26:48

Lol, this thread FAILS! Personally I like Scar better. + da SRL community is much more welcoming. LOL who voted rsbot they phail!

Main

2009-02-06 21:30:02

scar why?
Because I do not like the obvious client hacking rs bot.

Claymore

2009-02-06 21:32:36

Rsbot is awesome. This is just to bias since your posting it in SRL forums. If i posted a thread like this in Rsbot, who do you think will still win? Don't be an idiot and say SCAR. Unless you really are an idiot.

Main

2009-02-06 21:38:51

If you go on rsbot forum and tell em that rsbot is 100% detectable and scar is not. maybe…

Jimmy5410

2009-02-06 22:18:42

From: koo29
I once tried to get RSbot2, but when i went to the site where I get it, my bitdefender said that it just had blocked a virus. Very nice try form them…

RSBot 2 has not been released, so you probably did download some sort of infected file. I assume you weren't on the official RSBot forums.

From: Freddy1990
There's no comparison between the two, they're 2 completely different things…

Amen!

As for me, I actually came from the RSBot community. Their forums have been down for a while, and while the bot still works, I realized that RuneScape really is a dreadfully boaring game. After failing at making some RSBot scripts, I came here because I remember that SCAR is somewhat easier to code for (Only "Procedures", no "booleans" and "voids" and all the other stuff. As freddy said, they are two totally different things. Most people at RSBot have no idea what SCAR is all about, and most people here have no idea what RSBot is all about. Take for example this guy…
From: Luski14
RSBot is garbage.

That have:

  • Inexperienced Scripters
  • Little to ZERO Anti-Randoms
  • Bad Community - Not fun to hang around
  • SRL/SCAR is jsut a cooler name :D

Shit Compared to AutoRune Resource Library vs. RuneScape Bot…
In reality, the names are both pretty bad names, but they've been named what they are named for so long, there's no going back on it.

As for AntiRandoms, this guy has no idea what he is talking about. RSBot has every random solved with the exclusion of Gravedigger, Schoolhouse, and the Quiz Show with some of the other randoms messing up a bit.

From: Main_Ftw
If you go on rsbot forum and tell em that rsbot is 100% detectable and scar is not. maybe…

The people there aren't idiots… Well, some of them are, but you get my point.

In the end it really boils down to what you prefer: Client hacking vs. Color Picking

Client Hacking…
Pros: Less misclicking, easier coding
Cons: Must update more, detectable (Some Claim)

Color Clicking…
Pros: No updates, Easy Setup
Cons: Misclicking, less randoms

I know I only touched on the surface of this, but the fact is they are so different that it is utterly impossible to compare them.

My vote: -none-

Runescapian321

2009-02-06 22:42:44

From: Jimmy5410
RSBot 2 has not been released, so you probably did download some sort of infected file. I assume you weren't on the official RSBot forums.


Amen!

As for me, I actually came from the RSBot community. Their forums have been down for a while, and while the bot still works, I realized that RuneScape really is a dreadfully boaring game. After failing at making some RSBot scripts, I came here because I remember that SCAR is somewhat easier to code for (Only "Procedures", no "booleans" and "voids" and all the other stuff. As freddy said, they are two totally different things. Most people at RSBot have no idea what SCAR is all about, and most people here have no idea what RSBot is all about. Take for example this guy…

Shit Compared to AutoRune Resource Library vs. RuneScape Bot…
In reality, the names are both pretty bad names, but they've been named what they are named for so long, there's no going back on it.

As for AntiRandoms, this guy has no idea what he is talking about. RSBot has every random solved with the exclusion of Gravedigger, Schoolhouse, and the Quiz Show with some of the other randoms messing up a bit.


The people there aren't idiots… Well, some of them are, but you get my point.

In the end it really boils down to what you prefer: Client hacking vs. Color Picking

Client Hacking…
Pros: Less misclicking, easier coding
Cons: Must update more, detectable (Some Claim)

Color Clicking…
Pros: No updates, Easy Setup
Cons: Misclicking, less randoms

I know I only touched on the surface of this, but the fact is they are so different that it is utterly impossible to compare them.

My vote: -none-


Nice post :) Agreed. By the way, the RSBot forums aren't down. They're just very glitchy. Refresh like 15 times every time you click a link and you can look at it. Go to the announcements section and click the thread regarding the Internal Server error, it's explained there.

As for my opinion, I prefer RSBot for botting (pretty much my only justification for that is that I can run 5 RSBot clients vs 2 SMARTs), SRL for the much better community.

kingarabian

2009-02-06 23:55:06

From: Runescapian
Nice post :) Agreed. By the way, the RSBot forums aren't down. They're just very glitchy. Refresh like 15 times every time you click a link and you can look at it. Go to the announcements section and click the thread regarding the Internal Server error, it's explained there.

As for my opinion, I prefer RSBot for botting (pretty much my only justification for that is that I can run 5 RSBot clients vs 2 SMARTs), SRL for the much better community.


Same here.

When autoing on runescape color clicking by itself wont get the job done; and when using injection and hacking wont get the job done either. But combine both and you get better results.

lecrae1166

2009-02-07 00:11:24

biased to have this poll on a SCAR related forum.

turbobk

2009-02-07 07:32:09

From: DaWu
Its just a fact, that with java + all the reflection stuff, inexperienced scripter is capable of making as reliable scripts as experienced SCAR scripter.

But this is just pointless, SCAR is all about dodging the bans, being very hardly detectable. Java bots are usually slow functioning (example; dropping ), but then again reliable in many ways.

This is very pointless as stated before; SCAR is delphi/pascal and RSbot is java, both languages have their strong and weak sides, you just have to choose what you prefer.

People commonly claim javabots are more detectable, no they arent, they just lack multiplayer rotating + usualy are capable of doing overnight runs with just one character, and that does lead to ban in long run, because one characters ingame time/day starts to look suspicious, and will draw jagex's attention


Not being rude, but as a matter of fact Java bots ARE more detectable than Non-Java bots. Because they put hooks in the classes to extract Information from the client. Jagex could easily detect how many methods are in your client and if there are more they could ban based on that, which im not saying they do… but they could if they figured it out :rolleyes:

GoF

2009-02-07 08:50:16

RSBot would be teh sex if you could still freely trade goods from one account to another, as that's what it'd be good for (running multiple accounts at the same time and then passing the profits to another one etc.), but that doesn't work so well anymore, and when running a single account I find SCAR more reliable.

Runescapian321

2009-02-07 09:23:43

From: GoF
RSBot would be teh sex if you could still freely trade goods from one account to another, as that's what it'd be good for (running multiple accounts at the same time and then passing the profits to another one etc.), but that doesn't work so well anymore, and when running a single account I find SCAR more reliable.


Since my guys are all members (Pins in RSGP are pretty cheap these days), I find the dstone method pretty reliable ;)

tythus

2009-02-07 13:06:26

They both have advantages and disadvantages that's why they are both used

ritter74804

2009-02-08 00:18:37

I use rsbot but i herd about this site from a post and thought i would give it a try. i herd that the scripts was less likly to get you ban then there's was as soon as i can find a fishing/wc script i can use ill try it out. but rsbot seems easyer to use. so thay both have there good points

T3CH N9NE

2009-02-10 08:30:58

I've been using RsBot and it got me 90-99 def, then a perm ban. :) So, I'm back here at srl-forums. Rsbot has too many people who abuse it, and scar doesn't. Rsbot anti-randoms usually fail, and I think it's way to easy to get banned with it. I'm going to make a pure(legitly/autoing) with scar again.

Sandstorm

2009-02-10 08:41:56

From: Deathscytex
Rsbot is awesome. This is just to bias since your posting it in SRL forums. If i posted a thread like this in Rsbot, who do you think will still win? Don't be an idiot and say SCAR. Unless you really are an idiot.


And who has a Mordaut solver, Mime solver, and another one…. Can't remember.

:P.


~Sandstorm

freeloader900

2009-02-10 13:01:46

From: DaWu
People commonly claim javabots are more detectable, no they arent, they just lack multiplayer rotating + usualy are capable of doing overnight runs with just one character, and that does lead to ban in long run, because one characters ingame time/day starts to look suspicious, and will draw jagex's attention


Yeah, I've been banned twice before using both, so I'm pretty certain they're both as 'safe' as each other - got to keep on coming back to scar though:P!

xdustin

2009-02-12 09:44:26

SCAR + S.M.A.R.T. Over RSbot any day.

n3ss3s

2009-02-12 09:53:50

RSBot is more efficient to make scripts for, but that's just a small thing :)

Azz

2009-02-12 10:24:15

I prefer RSBot at moment because I yet haven't got into secrets of SCAR and it's easy and useful.

jakeyboy29

2009-02-12 12:36:58

who has all runescape randoms solved?

Sandstorm

2009-02-12 20:04:08

RSBot can't solve Mordaut I don't think, unless they updated it.

~Sandstorm

tvain

2009-02-12 20:13:05

the scripters are actually good……. almost anyone can learn how to make scripts for rsbot because its so simple. For anti-randoms they got lots. the only ones that can't be solved is the classroom exams and the maze.

I don't see how its a bad community? just the website is always down.

I like rsbot I don't know if scar/srl is better or shityer. I've never tried it but when I get 10 post ill have access to good scripts so ill update after thats done.

I've botted so much with rsbot its not even funny. Still no ban!!!! RSBot kicks ass

i've trained fishing from lvl 69-85
mined like 5mil worth of pure ess.

FROST-2oo8

2009-02-13 18:53:58

i think both of the bots are better for different things, rsbot you have more chance of a ban and wider range of scripts, srl not so many scripts and less chance of ban

miansc

2009-02-13 22:23:41

Rsbot scripting seems easier, bur srl has a way better community.

Smarter Child

2009-02-13 22:29:55

My decision on which is better is biased, for that i am sorry. Though for a fact, in my opinion, SRL is a much more welcoming community. If i joined the RsBot community in attempts to script for runescape then i would have quit. SRL pwns/:)

Edit:
From: FROST-2oo8
i think both of the bots are better for different things, rsbot you have more chance of a ban and wider range of scripts, srl not so many scripts and less chance of ban

SRL, has a variety of scripts! (i believe more than RsBot)

Metagen

2009-02-13 23:39:47

Rsbot > Scar + SRL

Reasons: Open source, object oriented, faster, fully reflective, better scripting environment, better client, better language, doesnt have freddy or benland in it, oh and did i mention faster?

and i personally dislike most of you anyways, so i dont care about either communities. i script for myself.

Automotron

2009-02-15 12:25:51

Hmm… why don't you ask a convent of nuns if they like satanic death metal?
I've never tried RSbot, but it's not worth the bother. SCAR is working fine for me.

yingying

2009-02-15 15:36:14

RSbot is way to risky to use, I love scar :3

T-BOLT

2009-02-15 16:16:46

Rsbot is better imo
It has way better anti bans
You can't imagine what you can do with rsbot
Its just am not yet a good enough scripter to make great things
e.g rsbot has an avianses killer,
look at this,
The bot hacks the client and get the current animation of other NPC's and yours this opens many possibilities,
they have great paths
I've also heard a rumor that Qbot and rsbot2 will have colour options
and i think SRl ill need to improve alot to have a chnace to beat Qbot and rsbot2

Method

2009-02-15 16:32:32

Our reflection can do just about everything RSBot can do, though not perhaps with the same efficiency because reflection doesn't use accessor methods.

MadSlash

2009-02-15 17:03:50

Scar is much better, RsBot is much more detectable, and crashes a lot

Gold

2009-02-15 17:10:38

Close this thread, First of all were are all incredibly biased second RSbot gets you banned so fast trust me

200 Posts booyah

mitch12555

2009-02-18 20:07:10

I have always used Rsbot, imma try Scar thou

imurbanlime

2009-02-18 21:43:07

Scar got me banned several times, I used RSBot and never gotten banned. Now I came back to Scar because I heard they improved the anti ban alot.

kensaurus

2009-02-19 11:50:12

Ive been using scar mainly, but recently i tried rsbot.
Honestly speaking, scar has lost quite alot to rsbot.
1/ Greater range of working scripts in rsbot.
2/ Their proggie appears on the screen, much convenient.(use it to understand)
3/Able to debug whole range of stuff.
Although their communities suck, but their client is a great possibility to many more wonderful scripts.
Keep working hard Scar!!!

Tickyy

2009-02-19 11:51:59

Some1 close this shit…

kensaurus

2009-02-19 14:27:29

try rsbot and u will know the difference dude.
closing this thread just shows that we are admitting defeat to rsbot.
we are all groups of people who aim to program to bot so why not learn some from other types of programming language?
each has their niches and bads.
btw rsbot antirandom is godlike.

Yo Yoker

2009-02-19 14:48:54

Srl/scar is better because scripts are better unbannable.

mormonman

2009-02-19 15:33:50

From: kensaurus
btw rsbot antirandom is godlike.


do they have mordaut… i didn't think so!
Edit: plus i don't think they ever will…

SKy Scripter

2009-02-19 16:02:18

does mormonman happen to live in utah? lol

mormonman

2009-02-19 16:14:05

From: SKy Scripter
does mormonman happen to live in utah? lol


no… arizona! lol

Gold

2009-02-19 20:09:44

Lol If you wanna talk about how bad RSbots community is a while back they had a porn section ROFL Bunch of asian kids botting then jerking it off

:eek:

mormonman

2009-02-19 20:15:13

From: goldrush655
Lol If you wanna talk about how bad RSbots community is a while back they had a porn section ROFL Bunch of asian kids botting then jerking it off

:eek:


they still have it…

Gold

2009-02-19 20:21:47

Wow thats disgusting come on man kids auto all the time hell I'm only 15

If you want it find your own haha

kensaurus

2009-02-21 07:21:35

lolz. just saw they got a soul wars script…
their production is much faster than here though i have to admit

ian.

2009-02-21 07:27:07

From: kensaurus
lolz. just saw they got a soul wars script…
their production is much faster than here though i have to admit


someone here made one already (he's my friend) but because of some events he's selling it :) it's a great script ^^

gameruiler

2009-02-21 18:57:46

everybody needs a good soul wars script…… and SCAR is way better than RSbot.

curran021

2009-02-21 22:20:13

they are basically the same thing at this point in time but i think scar has more scripts than rsbot

curran0021

2009-02-22 14:56:35

I personally use RSbot and i havent had any trouble with bans or crashing. I wanna try scar but i dont have my Junior Membership yet :)

Hugolord

2009-02-22 15:00:14

From: curran0021
I personally use RSbot and i havent had any trouble with bans or crashing. I wanna try scar but i dont have my Junior Membership yet :)


You don't need Junior Membership to try out scar. That is exactly why there is a "Free for all Scripts" section. :rolleyes:

lamo528

2009-02-25 23:35:19

i like srl alot better then rsbot because of the support and the directions on how to use a scar script between rsbot.

Zodia

2009-02-26 19:09:47

In response to the scripts debate.

RSBot have much more functioning scripts. Scripts that would be private here, have probably a free rsbot counterpart.

I would stick with SCAR though, it's more for users who actually want to learn.

While RSBot is for the unintelligent noob crowd.

Hint: Maybe if we talk about Rsbot and how noob friendly it is all then noobs here might leave and SCAR we become less common and harder to detect other than some noobs who like to abuse our scripts.

Hugolord

2009-02-26 19:11:46

From: Zodia
In response to the scripts debate.

RSBot have much more functioning scripts. Scripts that would be private here, have probably a free rsbot counterpart.

I would stick with SCAR though, it's more for users who actually want to learn.

While RSBot is for the unintelligent noob crowd.

Hint: Maybe if we talk about Rsbot and how noob friendly it is all then noobs here might leave and SCAR we become less common and harder to detect other than some noobs who like to abuse our scripts.

how is it you people don't understand that jagex can detect rsbot?

DemonKing7

2009-02-26 19:13:36

Both are very good but SCAR just has better antiban AND i am starting to like this community better then the RSbot one.

Runescapian321

2009-02-26 19:17:24

From: Hugolord
how is it you people don't understand that jagex can detect rsbot?


I auto(ed) with my main for the past month with it for like 20 hours a week with RSBot. He's not banned.

However I'm switching to SRL now since all the randoms are solved :)