SRL Archive - RuneScape News and General

Iron or Essence? Which is more profitable? (GP)


tatootian

2007-10-08 15:36:52

I know… This might seem like an obvious question… but you know… Essence takes less time than Iron, but Iron pays off more…

What do you guys think I should do, or what everyone who's asking this same question

Boreas

2007-10-08 15:38:55

Some say that the infinite runes update will drive the cost of ess down…

Rikje

2007-10-08 15:57:20

@boreas, other poeple think that it will rise :p.

iron sells faster then ess. because there allready a lot of ess bots.

richk1693

2007-10-08 15:59:13

i vote iron. I'm stuck with like 5k ess that nobody on earth will buy.

Pyro

2007-10-08 18:06:37

Iron plus it will level you faster ( I think) And coal is by far the best once you get mining guild. Well so i think anyways.

gamer 5

2007-10-08 18:30:15

I would go with iron, then consider coal!!

tatootian

2007-10-08 19:42:12

Erm… I have 70 mining, but I don't see a Mining Guild autoer? :o Or am I blind? D:

Gabe

2007-10-08 20:38:12

Iron, but I dunno about ess prices. Water runes at the Port Sarim rune shop went from 5 ea at full stock to 17 ea at infinite stock…

Runescape Pro

2007-10-08 21:52:38

I would personally do iron. I used to run wizzup?'s ess miner all the time, but it only raked in about 300k per 5 days (only used 2 characters)… im currently using masterkill's varrock east iron miner and have already gotten about 700k+ in like 5 days with two characters that one went from 42 or 43 mining to aroung 57 mining.

PwNZoRNooB

2007-10-09 00:57:12

I'm confused with the ess price, will it rise or will it drop. I've got some excitement on this because I have about 30k of ess on my hands :D

But I think I'll start mining them both to avoid ban with script changing. :)

gillian

2007-10-09 02:48:03

I think that I am going to do iron :) iron and coal will never go out of style ;)

Czepa

2007-10-09 05:42:54

From: Pyro
Iron plus it will level you faster ( I think) And coal is by far the best once you get mining guild. Well so i think anyways.
i'm not sure if its applicable these days… BUT back in the last mining boom (guildraper) prices were down below 150 and some people were even selling at 100 ea. (very stupid? i know) and from experience iron is a much better ore to mine for profit - on the basis that you are selling it raw.. that is, unless coal is sold at 180-200. in my opinion, coal is a good time/profit resource until the guildminers bring it down to 160

legendaryhero90

2007-10-09 08:26:56

iron then coal.

ess is worthless now. :(

mynameisjoe

2007-10-15 21:22:08

I would have to go with essence on this one. Because wizzups ess miner is an amazing script, and even if the price drops, you can still get essence faster than iron. Plus, varrok essence mine is closer to the bank than any iron mine is.

Hobbit

2007-10-15 21:25:50

Defenatly iron.
I have almost 15k esse on the Script competition prize account I've been trying to sell but no one buys.

*cough* Pm me if you would like to donate *cough*
Sorry about the lil ad blurb ;)

Lacky

2007-10-16 06:03:47

Iron.

Runescape Pro

2007-10-16 07:04:40

look at my sig =P
iron is by far the best and i already have 10k on 1 account(thats 1mil)…

@hobbit: do you get anything for donating? im considering donating 5k iron.

~rs2pro

Markus

2007-10-16 12:28:55

Iron, gives 7 times more xp, and is more profitable then rune ess. (for members pure ess owns iron)

IronTeapot

2007-10-16 14:23:12

My guys go for iron, much more prefered than essence. Works their lvls up to coal faster too. Though i think ill keep them as iron miners anyways. Get iron faster than coal for quite a few levels.

legendaryhero90

2007-10-16 20:53:33

IRON FTW!

though i hate gas…

The Claw

2007-10-18 04:28:49

Probably gold from the crafting guild, roughly 50k gp an hour

R0b0t1

2007-10-18 21:45:53

In a fight bewtween essence and iron, Chuck Norris would when.

josh81193

2007-10-18 22:45:19

From: R0b0t1
In a fight bewtween essence and iron, Chuck Norris would when.


im with robot, Chuck Norris would kick there ass

f2p, iron owns untill ur like 65+ minin and mine coal, or if ur a member then mine pure ess and sell to nat crafters! that would just own almost everything, 'cept Chuck Norris

Eugeniu

2007-10-19 00:25:54

IRON PWNZ! Mostly because I got so tired of my 10k ess in my bank that I just gave it away…lmao. But iron on the other hand…

ParkaCarl

2008-01-18 17:48:43

iron is super expensive now…. is the only source of it because of summonining? or did the update hit a lot of the mining autoers, which in turn make it even more expensive?

L3ss Than 33

2008-01-18 19:16:08

I would say pure essence (p2p).
Is that a choice? It's worth a lot more than plain old essence, and the speed is still there!

proresearch

2008-01-19 12:41:49

pure essence is way faster u get about 800 per hour at 87 mining and 125 gp each in GE, is good money i get like 400 iron ores an hour so go figure. 100k vs 40k you decide.

stnrscott2

2008-01-19 12:51:14

IMO, Iron.

Mining exp, good pay off.

L3ss Than 33

2008-01-19 20:46:23

From: stnrscott2
IMO, Iron.

Mining exp, good pay off.


The title says (gp) in parenthesis. So if you want exp, go for iron, gp go for pure essence.