SRL Archive - Music, Movies and TV

Star Wars VII


GRIM

2014-12-01 02:35:53

[YOUTUBE]OMOVFvcNfvE[/YOUTUBE]

Who's hardcore into star wars and is as stoked for this movie as I am,
I don't give any shits about Disney or JJ Abrams doing anything to butcher the legacy but I wondered what other people thought about it?

only another year

Jordantimber

2014-12-01 04:34:28

33 millions views and still counting. Need i say more:spongebob:

Incurable

2014-12-01 05:13:18

A droid rolling a football at high speeds? Calling it now, here comes a brand new set of terrible Star Wars movies, as though the prequels didn't shit all over the franchise badly enough, lol.

onilika

2014-12-01 08:06:08

Looks promising. The only thing where I have doubt is that red light saber … I think they should rethink it, or have a plausible explanation for it (how it won't cut its own hand?).
And, if you check those previous trailers from the other movies, you'll see this one is the best so far :p So… like Jordantimber said… those numbers escalated quickly!! And counting.

rj

2014-12-01 10:29:41

here come the die hard starwars fans to refute Disney's changes!

Kevin

2014-12-01 10:32:46

From: onilika
Looks promising. The only thing where I have doubt is that red light saber … I think they should rethink it, or have a plausible explanation for it (how it won't cut its own hand?).


The part that bothers me the most about it, is that it's designed with a guard for catching enemy blades… But the base of the guard is still the actual lightsaber base which can be cut fine… Which means that it's a guard for show only as it can't actually guard. The extra side blades literally only exist as a danger for the wielder and can't be used offensively or defensively in any manner.

i luffs yeww

2014-12-01 15:48:14

From: Kevin
The part that bothers me the most about it, is that it's designed with a guard for catching enemy blades… But the base of the guard is still the actual lightsaber base which can be cut fine… Which means that it's a guard for show only as it can't actually guard. The extra side blades literally only exist as a danger for the wielder and can't be used offensively or defensively in any manner.


Not necessarily true. There are a handful of materials which can resist lightsabers to varying degrees. Although yes, the crossblade design itself is a bit dangerous to the actual wielder, I'd say it's not too far fetched to assume that whoever is using that blade knows how to safely use it. I'd rather see something than nothing, anyway. The fact it's taken this long even for the idea of some sort of hand protection is a bit absurd itself, although everyone seems to make fun of the idea.

Clarity

2014-12-01 15:54:53

From: i luffs yeww
Not necessarily true. There are a handful of materials which can resist lightsabers to varying degrees. Although yes, the crossblade design itself is a bit dangerous to the actual wielder, I'd say it's not too far fetched to assume that whoever is using that blade knows how to safely use it. I'd rather see something than nothing, anyway. The fact it's taken this long even for the idea of some sort of hand protection is a bit absurd itself, although everyone seems to make fun of the idea.


I saw in some angry YouTube comment war that apparently this "special guard-lightsaber that Disney/JJ Abrams came up with" actually is common in the Star Wars universe beyond the movies, and this new movie is just recreating that, so the "hardcore fans" are actually getting mad at what they claim to be hardcore fans of.

Besides that, this movie looks really cool. I've enjoyed all 6 movies so far, so I expect this one will be enjoyable as well.

i luffs yeww

2014-12-01 16:11:33

From: Clarity
I saw in some angry YouTube comment war that apparently this "special guard-lightsaber that Disney/JJ Abrams came up with" actually is common in the Star Wars universe beyond the movies, and this new movie is just recreating that, so the "hardcore fans" are actually getting mad at what they claim to be hardcore fans of.

Besides that, this movie looks really cool. I've enjoyed all 6 movies so far, so I expect this one will be enjoyable as well.


I honestly can't find anywhere reliable (YouTube comments are not a reliable source) showing any lightsaber designs similar to what's shown in the trailer. Even if it has existed before (I hope it has, honestly - my biggest gripe with sci-fi is that the technological progressions never make sense. Why are humans flying space ships that fire lasers into space like it's no big deal? Those lasers don't decelerate, and they'll hit something eventually. It would be mayhem. We hardly let people fly or shoot things these days, especially not for anything important like missile defense or the like), I can't say it's "common." I doubt everyone on the internet other than YouTube commenters missed out on that aspect of Star Wars.

Kevin

2014-12-01 16:34:44

From: i luffs yeww
I honestly can't find anywhere reliable (YouTube comments are not a reliable source) showing any lightsaber designs similar to what's shown in the trailer. Even if it has existed before (I hope it has, honestly - my biggest gripe with sci-fi is that the technological progressions never make sense. Why are humans flying space ships that fire lasers into space like it's no big deal? Those lasers don't decelerate, and they'll hit something eventually. It would be mayhem. We hardly let people fly or shoot things these days, especially not for anything important like missile defense or the like), I can't say it's "common." I doubt everyone on the internet other than YouTube commenters missed out on that aspect of Star Wars.


In the link you gave me about light-saber resistant materials, further down describes that lightsaber and some wielders of it I believe (I read a lot of that page out of curiosity).

As for shooting lasers into space, they dissipate after a while, haven't you ever played any Star Wars game? In reality though, as they move at the speed of light, you'd never really see them shoot like they do, and more importantly, they actually would dissipate. Between hitting microscopic dust filtered throughout space slowly taking away it's heat and power, it would also slowly flare out. No matter how hard you want a light-based shot to be a simple line, it will only possibly become a thinner cone. It will eventually flare out to a perfectly safe width. For an Earth based example, it would be pretty much impossible to shoot the moon with a laser of power, no matter how powerful it is, as even incredibly precise and thin lasers would become kilometers in diameter by the time they got even that far.

masterBB

2014-12-01 18:26:12

From: Kevin
In the link you gave me about light-saber resistant materials, further down describes that lightsaber and some wielders of it I believe (I read a lot of that page out of curiosity).

As for shooting lasers into space, they dissipate after a while, haven't you ever played any Star Wars game? In reality though, as they move at the speed of light, you'd never really see them shoot like they do, and more importantly, they actually would dissipate. Between hitting microscopic dust filtered throughout space slowly taking away it's heat and power, it would also slowly flare out. No matter how hard you want a light-based shot to be a simple line, it will only possibly become a thinner cone. It will eventually flare out to a perfectly safe width. For an Earth based example, it would be pretty much impossible to shoot the moon with a laser of power, no matter how powerful it is, as even incredibly precise and thin lasers would become kilometers in diameter by the time they got even that far.


I just leave this here:
http://what-if.xkcd.com/13/

GRIM

2014-12-01 19:25:57

From: Robert
here come the die hard starwars fans to refute Disney's changes!

this

From: Kevin
The part that bothers me the most about it, is that it's designed with a guard for catching enemy blades… But the base of the guard is still the actual lightsaber base which can be cut fine… Which means that it's a guard for show only as it can't actually guard. The extra side blades literally only exist as a danger for the wielder and can't be used offensively or defensively in any manner.


Before the other comments i was hoping there was a part in VII where the presumed sith takes out a guy on his left and right by using the force to control the saber.

Kevin

2014-12-02 10:16:22

From: masterBB
I just leave this here:
http://what-if.xkcd.com/13/


Well, it seems to have mostly agreed with me. Although it did present a crazy powerful laser array to an extent that I kind of want to see now. Even if we all die.

Incurable

2014-12-02 10:38:34

From: masterBB
I just leave this here:
http://what-if.xkcd.com/13/


That is awesome, I've often wondered what would really happen, though I always suspected that that would be the case.

ftwrain

2014-12-03 23:05:50

I seriously can't wait to watch it .
Some people might hate it but I mean what did you expect , you're not going to get the same old acters and things have to upgrade like gear , weapons etc.

everve

2014-12-04 01:42:24

I am honestly so incredibly excited for this movie. So far it looks pretty promising to me and I can't wait to see more. I'm hoping they feel the pressure after the disappointment of the last 3. I'll leave this here for everyone who has issues with the new light saber design:

[video=youtube;ZYlvatkLU0U]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZYlvatkLU0U[/video]