From: samerdl
Am in the mood for typing, forgive me for rambling..
OSRS has been at a state of decline for a while, the game legitimately requires real F2P worlds & proper advertising, with that said - the community is still relatively active (10k+ players playing, had around 20k+ during f2p weekend, jagex aren't wise).
Now if you're interested in advancing your scripting wisdom then go ahead, script; don't expect a large user base.
Personally i haven't used Simba much since Java bots started popping up for OSRS, to me Simba/Scar have always been transition programs - things to use when there is nothing else to use at the time, but hey i don't even play RS/OSRS anymore - you shouldn't either! Jagex are a failed company and they don't deserve support for their degenerate services.
I really agree with this.
Let's outline a few points here;
1. OSRS is nowhere near as active as RS3. That's a fact. 50k+ online on RS3, and OSRS is luck to hit 15k.
Just Google the results of the poll if you want. OSRS barely got 400k votes to come back. There's not a huge percentage of the playerbase that plays it.
2. OSRS, by nature, will decline steadily until it's as dead as RSC. Want proof? Go look at RSC's world counter. We're lucky to get 75 people online
total (all 3 servers). Yes I still play RSC and it sucks that no one is ever on.
RSC was presented in exactly the same way as OSRS was (albeit almost 8 years ago).
3. Reflection macroing clients for OSRS are far more efficient than color-based macros can ever be. This actually isn't the case with RS3, but two major differences somewhat alienate Simba from OSRS:
The fact that reflection is still possible to use as a cheating method, and
the fact that bans in OSRS are nowhere near where they are in RS3.
As
@samerdl; said, Simba has been and always will be a fallback, the thing everyone uses when nothing else is working. Granted, Simba has a reflection library for OSRS but the very nature of Simba and the SRL community pretty much renders that point moot.
Why? Because Simba, staying true to SCAR's age-old legacy, is not a bot. I want to call it a CDE (cheat development environment) but it's not even that. It's a program that happens to be very good at playing RuneScape (with the aid of SRL/SRL-OSR). Also by definition, it's nowhere near as user-friendly as other macros. The reason Simba has always been somewhat shunted to the side is just what I outlined earlier; it's a fallback.
I'm not even trying to be rude, I myself only discovered Simba
after the bot nuke two years ago. I hadn't a clue that any color-based scriptable macros beyond SCAR ever existed. Why? Because I was sucked in by the bigger names in RuneScape cheating at that time: NeXus, RSBuddy, EpicBot, powerbot.
Don't get me wrong, I think Simba is the best macro out there, but it's just plain confusing. I don't think anyone will disagree with me on that point, at least not from the average RS player/botter's point of view (and we all know how stupid they can be).
Once upon a time, every RS cheater was smart and individualized and determined and willing to learn–but that's simply not the case anymore. And that's why Simba will always remain in the backseat.
Which isn't all bad! We have a great (albeit close-knit) community here. We can accomplish the same tasks in manners that other cheating communities cannot.